Category Archives: Uncategorized

A Season Full of Gold

Almost six years ago now, I moved to Georgia to pursue a job. Pretty wild to think how quick time can fly, and how every year brings its own unpredictabilities that can bring both challenge and joy to life. With that being said, I’m a believer that wherever you live, it is crucial to have a handful of consistent people and activities to look forward to in order to maintain internal peace. Since moving to Georgia, I can say with confidence that one thing each and every year keeps me amped up for 6 months: Carp Season.

As those that are kind enough to follow this blog know, I’m a huge fan of the carp fishing opportunities in Georgia. I’ve fly fished for carp for nearly my entire life (and in countless places throughout the United States), and I can truly say that carping here is among the best. Not only can the numbers of carp here be unparalleled, but the sheer size of some of these fish is insanee. To emphasize further, the largest carp that I have seen in my entire life have been in Georgia.

In 2024, the word I would use to describe the season would be “unreal”. I caught my largest common carp ever this year, and several amazing, very large fish were brought to hand. In between these fish were countless other terrific carp that kept drag screaming, smiles on faces, and paddle boards getting pulled around.

Joe Petrow – Carp

Due to the sheer amount of carp outings had throughout the year, I’m not going to do a “play by play” in this post, but instead go through some of my biggest lessons learned and highlight a few specific fish outings.

From a lessons learned perspective, these were the three common themes throughout the year:

  • When in doubt, have a “grub” fly ready. Although I have a handful of patterns that I’m confident a carp will eat, my hand-tied grub patterns this year produced the most amount of fish. They can be deadly with a “drag and drop”, and there were some difficult days in which this was the only fly the carp would be open to.
  • Don’t be stubborn on leader/tippet size. I traditionally am a fan of 15lb tapered to 12lb fluoro, but found that my landing rates on BIG fish increased this year on straight 15lb as I could horse some of the fish that were attempting to take the fight into structure. The heavier tippet may lead to less eats on tough days, but it’s worth it if you have a better chance to land large fish.
  • Don’t overlook an early evening paddle/outing. Although the majority of my carp days were mornings (lower wind, less people on the water), a few of my most productive sessions of the season were between the hours of 3pm-6pm. Lesson here is give it a go whenever you can.
Joe Petrow – Carp

From a highlighting of a few fish/outings perspective, these were the big three:

  • As mentioned earlier, I caught my largest common carp this year. This fish slowly slurped a grub fly and proceeded to put up the craziest fight I’ve had on the paddle board. This fish was absolutely 25+ pounds.
  • I caught my first, large Koi/Carp hybrid this year. The spawn was an extra sight to behold this year (hundreds of carp going crazy), and for about a month you could catch the non-spawning fish in thee midst of the spawning fish. Wild to watch.
  • Earlier this year, my larger Bote board when out of commission (we had a great run). In the interim of purchasing a new one, I did a few carp outings on my much smaller paddle board. I landed a huge common carp on this board that dragged me all over the place for 10+minutes, and I had to get out to land it without falling in. Good news was that it took me close to a shallow flat!
Joe Petrow – Koi/Carp
Joe Petrow – Carp

Cannot wait for Carp Season 2025 and always grateful for these fish! Long live the carp.

Tight lines!

Joe Petrow

Baja Birthdays

Although I believe that every birthday should be a day to reflect, celebrate, and make some time to do the things that bring you joy, there are a few birthdays that seem to have more “weight” to them. For me this year, I hit the big 30 (and my girl friend hit the big 29) and we decided to add a little extra flare to the birthday travel plans. We landed on Cabo and I selfishly was salivating at the thoughts to throw some line and see what happens.

Having never fly fished in Cabo before, I didn’t fully know what to expect other than the content I have seen online surrounding Roosterfish, Mahi, Jacks, Tuna, Marlin, etc. Although I made sure to book an afternoon from a boat for one day during the week, I was most excited about the chance to find some fish from shore.

Upon arrival at the hotel in Cabo, the water was gorgeous. Deep blue, relatively calm, lots of rocks around – I thought it was going to be easy to hook some snappers, groupers, and other reef species around the rocks. Upon fishing for hours the first two days, my assumption proved to be majorly WRONG…only had some action with a few very (very) small reef fish. With that said, we had our half day charter coming up, so wasn’t horribly concerned about us finding some fish at some point.

For the spirit of full transparency, the half day charter was extremely difficult and a bit of a cluster. The winds in Cabo this week were brutal (especially in the afternoon) and we were met with consistent 25-30 mph gusts and significant waves while on the boat – this obviously limited the number of areas in which we could throw a fly line. In addition to this, with my girlfriend in tow, I knew as soon as we launched that there was no way we would be spending 4+ hours in the conditions. With that said, we were able to get the fish monkey off our back this day by catching the largest Jack Crevalle of my life. There was a school of about 20 fish, and it absolutely hammered a big white baitfish fly made with bucktail/white hackle. Put a crazy bend on the 10-weight, so not complaining!

Joe Petrow – Jack Crevalle

The day after our charter, I made the decision to abandon the rocky areas I was previously targeting and go scout a public beach that was a further walk away. What a decision that panned out to be as it was like a light switch turned on…

Although the wind was still howling, I immediately saw bait fished being blitzed on 10-feet from the shore, and was hooked up on my first cast with a larger white/chartreuse clouser minnow. New species! Gaffttopsail Pompano – these guys don’t get very large, but put up quite the bend in the 8-weight. I caught about four of these guys (in addition to some smaller Green Jacks and Jack Crevalles) rather quickly, but the weird thing was that the fish I saw blitzing were not pompano…they looked like tuna. Curious as to what was crashing bait, I down sized my fly to a very simple white baitfish pattern, and immediately was hooked up. Skipjack tuna! An unreal fight for their size, and was catching fish after fish for about a 30-minute period. Easily landed over half a dozen.

After the blitz was over, this is when things got interesting. I slowly started my walk back to the hotel and saw a 10-15 pound fish swimming 60 feet off the beach. ROOSTERFISH…seemingly just gliding through the waves. I rushed to get a cast in front of this…strip strips strip…holy cow the fish is following…all the way up to my feet…denied. What a bummer. but it happens. MORE IMPORTANTLY – I found Roosters. Within the next 15-minutes, more fish arrived. A pack of 3 fish and a few more singles. I had a handful of great throws that led to the same result of the roosters chasing it all the way in but not committing. I also had just as many “yikes” throws that the optimist in me still wonders if I would’ve caught one of these bigger roosters had I not been a slacker. After getting humbled by these fish for a couple more hours (and being rather sad that we would be heading back home the next day), I headed back to the hotel to celebrate my girlfriends birthday with some great food and margaritas.

The last morning of the trip is where I was blessed with the perfect ending. I decided to wake up super early and see if the roosters were still along the beach before needing to head to the airport. I had never caught a Roosterfish on the fly before, and really was itching to check this one off my species list. While targeting the larger fish the day before, I noticed that several small baby Roosterfish were zipping around the wave breaks, so I decided to rig up a smaller whit and red deceiver fly and just focus on getting one of these guys. Upon arriving to the beach, I saw a baby rooster zip and zag right by the shore…put a throw into the wave breaks…and finally! Rooster on. Although this Rooster was in no way a giant, it meant everything and put up quite the battle. I made sure to just snap a quick selfie with this fish and get it back in the water quickly so it could grow to be the giant it deserves to be.

Joe Petrow – Roosterfish

What a trip and what a time. I cannot wait to chase Roosters again in the future, as they really are an amazing fish that I’d like to spend the time getting to know better. The moments when the hard work pay off is makes fly fishing so rewarding, and I’ll never forget the memories made this trip for my 30th. My first drink as a 30-year old was a cold margarita with my girlfriend on the beach, and my first fish as a 30-year old was a Rooster on the beach. Can’t beat that.

Tight lines!

Joe

Long Weekend Stripers

As most serious fly fisherman can relate to, the fish you frequently target can often evolve throughout the course of your life. Some fish you grow up with, and some fish join the journey later in life – both have a special place in your heart. For me, Striped Bass (specifically in Maine) were one of those fish that I really started to become ecstatic about later in my twenties. Over the past couple of years, I’ve continued to dedicate the time (on both the water and fly tying vice) to learn more about how to catch Stripers, and our annual trip to Maine in 2024 led to some of the best encounters I’ve had with these fish.

Similar to pervious years, we ventured to Maine in late May, and were met with the best possible weather conditions (not an exaggeration). Super sunny skies, warmer temps for the early summer, and low winds. Although Stripers typically prefer some clouds/wind/elements to really turn on the feed bag, the sunny conditions on this trip really allowed some terrific opportunities to sight fish. To mix it up from previous years, I wanted to do two things this trip when it came to fishing: throw bigger flies and find new water. Although I had a few terrific spots that produced fish on my usual clouser/smaller baitfish patterns, I really wanted to throw some larger bucktail patterns and explore my “spot” horizons. With that said, I was optimistic that this could be a fishy weekend, as I was able to catch a nice striper on a larger bucktail fly (in one of my usual areas) on the very first evening in Maine. This fish was sitting in a HEAVY outgoing tide and hammered the fly only about 5 feet from the trip of the rod, and put up quite the fight. After a few quick shots, the fish swam off strongly and I went to go celebrate with a blueberry beer.

Joe Petrow – Striped Bass

The next day ended up being a day that really one that dreams are made of when it comes to throwing some fly line. My girlfriend and I slept in a bit, picked up some donuts, and arrived to a new fishing area that I wanted to check out by about 10am. I had my same larger bucktail fly on from the evening before, along with an intermediate sinking line to help get the fly down if current was present. Within about 30-minutes of walking the beach and jetty looking for fish, I couldn’t believe my eyes…there was a school of about 25-35 striped bass circling the beach about 80 feet off the shore. I sat and watched these fish slowly get closer to the rocks/shore, and tried to keep my heartbeat down and fly line ready. The school of fish settled in about 60 feet out and I let out a long cast…let the big fly slowly sink…did some quick sporadic strips…and the fish were on it! Four to five fish started chasing but not committing, until finally a BIG striper came up and engulfed it. Striper on! The fight that ensued became utter chaos from the rocks, and I was able to fortunately land this fish for an awesome picture. This was my largest striper to date, and I was extremely grateful for the moment.

Joe Petrow – Striper

For the next hour, the school continued to patrol the area, and I was able to land 3 more fish (had another get off by the rocks). All of the fish were extremely nice, but not as big as the first one). Similar to the first fish, these stripers were all over the larger fly – just had to adjust the strip based on the body language of the fish. I threw to one specific fish multiple times, until finally I ripped the fly as fast as I could and then it finally hammered it. You could tell that the sunny conditions definitely had these fish a little skeptical to eat, but the sheer number of fish in the school kept them aggressive enough (and competitive to beat each other to the fly) where it didn’t prevent fish from being caught.

Joe Petrow – Striper

As for the final day of the weekend, we returned to the same area, and was able to land one smaller Striper and hook another. The large school was no longer there, but I noticed some fish sitting in the fast current a little bit closer towards a river mouth. Had a few very nice fish (including one possibly bigger than the first day) chase the bigger flies in, but not commit. I ultimately down sized the fly to focus on the smaller fish I was seeing, and this proved to work.

Joe Petrow – Striper

As always, can’t wait for the next trip up to Maine and continuing to put the time in to go after these awesome fish.

Tight lines!

Joe Petrow

Tarpon, Triggers, and Right Place at the Right Time

This year, I was fortunate enough to have a rewards trip for work get scheduled in the Bahamas. Although I would’ve loved nothing more than to spend this entire week with my girlfriend searching for bonefish on one of the lesser populated islands of the Bahamas, this trip required some work, making me get creative when it came to finding some productive time to throw a fly rod. One thing that really held true to me in 2024 was “when in doubt, bring a fly rod if you’re going to the beach”, and this trip was no exception.

Although the water in the Bahamas was beautiful upon arrival, the area we were in was in no way secluded. Several resorts around, lots of boats in the water…that kind of deal. With that said, I had some hopes that if I just started putting in some miles on the sand that MAYBE I would be able to see something swimming around. Fortunately for me, I lucked out, found some fish, and made the most out of these rare opportunities.

During our first afternoon “off”, my girlfriend and I walked to a considerably less busy flat about a mile away from the hotel. Upon arriving to the flat, life was obvious. Stingrays swimming around, schools of extremely small baitfish getting bothered by baby barracudas…all extremely positive signs. I had a small shrimp pattern tied on (very optimistically thinking that maybe a bonefish would be around), and this would turn out to be a good call but for a different reason. After catching a few very small snappers throwing into a single deep hole off the flat, I noticed a big, dark tail appear on the flat itself. After staring at the tail for a good 20 seconds wondering what it was, I finally realized that it was a large Ocean Triggerfish and got to casting. Follow after follow…I got this fish excited on the fly. It would swipe at it, miss, swipe again, eat it but not get the hook in the face…until finally my line went fully tight after a surge towards the fly from the fish. Trigger on and the fight was unreal! This fish took me deep into backing on the first run, and easily took 10-minutes to get in. This was my first Ocean Triggerfish and I was ecstatic to get this guy off the beach.

Joe Petrow – Triggerfish

Later in the week, I took an early morning walk on the beach the following day, I noticed a pod of four to six juvenile tarpon patrolling around (!!!). These fish were swimming parallel on a specific stretch of the beach that seemed to have a slightly deeper trough about 30-feet off the beach. Having been on the search for more triggerfish again, I had a small shrimp fly tied on, and made the decision to switch flies as quick (and calmly) as I could. I had a few of my go to black craft fur and bucktail flies in my box, and got one rigged relatively quick (considering how much blood I had pumping). Fortunately for me, the fish had maybe only moved down 200 feet on the beach and I was able to track them down, get a leading cast out, and boom…tarpon on. After several jumps, unlimited head shakes, and a few too close to call moments right by the waves breaking, I was able to land this fish. What an awesome moment from foot right off the beach.

Joe Petrow – Tarpon

The moral of the story from these fish is when in doubt, bring a rod with you to the beach. Even though there will be many times where nothing is seen, the times where fish decide to show up makes it all worth it.

Tight lines!

Joe

Return to the Bayou

Every year, I need time on (and near) the water with those that I care about the most for my heart to feel full. Since I’ve been in middle school, spending time with my Dad fly fishing for Redfish in Louisiana has been something that has not only produced some unreal fish, but some of the best laughs, meals, and conversations as well. Luckily enough this year, we were able to return to the bayou to celebrate a birthday and chase after some nice fish.

Fishing in the spring can be a great time in Louisiana – the colder weather of the winter is gone, but big fish can still be found. For this trip specifically, we were fortunate from a weather perspective as Mother Nature held up. Not terrible winds, some sun in the sky…two blessings when you are in the marsh. Especially when you are fishing in a limited number of days and need to make each hour count.

As for the fishing itself on this strip, solid would probably be the word. Although nice weather was had, we were in a bit of a transition period after a cold front the week before, which didn’t have the reds schooled up (which typically makes life much easier). With that said, after putting in the hours, we were able to find some outstanding fish and make our opportunities count.

Not seeing large groups of fish had us actively searching the shoreline. After a slow first couple of hours on our first day, we started to see “single” reds swimming parallel to the shore pushing big wakes and having their backs out of the water. Close casts with dark colored flies were the trick here due to some murky water. Upon the proper fly delivery, we were provided with a handful of nice reds throughout the day – there really is nothing like the search and pull from a bid redfish.

Joe Petrow – Redfish
Joe Petrow – Redfish

In addition to this, we were able to land an extremely nice black drum on Day 1. As those who fish the marsh will know, these fish are absolutely catchable on the fly, but have the fraction of an attitude (and appetite) of a red. Slow strips and having the fly fall slowly right on this fish’s nose did the trick!

Joe Petrow – Black Drum

As for Day 2, it was a bit of a grind. We started off super hot by catching a nice red after spotting it from what seemed like a football field away (always awesome), but then really didn’t see a ton of life until the early afternoon. Fortunately, everything seemed to turn on in a major way in the last couple hours of day light. It seemed like we were starting to spook a good number of fish in the muddy water, and then we ultimately found some very large fish on the bank. We were able to make our throws count, and land a couple of very nice fish before we needed to head back to the launch. Similar to the day before (and most of the time in Louisiana), tight throws led to aggressive fish, and we were able to end our trip on a high note. Both of the fish below were high and happy, ready to eat a fly!

Joe Petrow – Redfish
Joe Petrow – Redfish

As I’ve shared on this site before, time on the water with my Dad will forever be one of my favorite things on this planet. Beyond lucky to be able to do this together, and getting to celebrate his birthday along with the fishing this year was icing on the cake.

Tight lines,

Joe e

Canal Hopping for Peacocks

South Florida…in my opinion, one of the best locations in the entire United States to throw a fly line (especially if you are like me where the more species encountered, the better). Although many people associate South Florida fly fishing with hitting the saltwater towards the Keys, my mind immediately thinks about the canals in Miami/Fort Lauderdale where you can find species that are no where else in the country. In addition to this, when the rest of the country is dealing with colder weather and fishing seasons winding down, South Florida remains warm enough where you can escape to a convenient “paradise” for a few days and get on some fish.

I was fortunate enough this year to visit the Miami area twice (once in January and then once in November), and during theses visits, I was able to find and catch a fan favorite… the Peacock bass. I found most of these fish in two specific canal systems in shallow water.

To kick it off, the conditions presented a major challenge. Peacock bass (with origins from the hot, humid climate of South America) THRIVE off of warm weather and warm water, and you will have an exceedingly difficult time finding them during big cold fronts. I ran into cold fronts in both January and November, but fortunately was able to figure a few things out and find some areas that held fish. Although the fishing was tougher, I found that doing the following produced the most fish for me: sleep in and only fish during the warmest part of the day, and strip the fly as fast as you possibly can. For full transparency (as I like to do on this site), I woke up super early two mornings thinking that this might have active fish, only to find out (and even see) that these fish weren’t ready and warm enough to eat.

Once it was warm enough, flies were eaten, fights were had, and beautiful fish were brought to hand. The best thing about fly fishing for peacocks is how visual it can be – these fish are often times hugging the shore shallow, allowing you to sight fish to your hearts desire. If you fish for them during the spring and summer (which I’d honestly recommend over the colder months), you can even find these fish on aggressive and shallow on beds. For my outings this year, I found my best peacocks under vegetation waiting in ambush to smack prey. Throwing any small white or chartreuse deer hair fly, and stripping as fast as I could, did the trick! I sight fished the below peacock (one of my largest ever) in this exact fashion, and it put up a terrific fight on the 8-weight.

Joe Petrow – Peacock Bass

Although I had a handful of successful outings, I very much look forward to returning to the canal systems during warmer months of the year to see if larger numbers of “bigger” fish can be found. I’m a big fan of any sized peacock as they are one of the most beautiful and best fighting fish you can find (great examples of what I’m talking about below) I’d love to sharpen my skillset on consistently finding larger fish. I also need to commit some time to searching for Snakeheads and Clown Knifefish on the fly!

Joe Petrow – Peacock Bass

In addition to this, I do want to highlight that the largemouth bass fishing seems to improve with some colder weather. While searching pretty exclusively for peacocks, I caught countless largemouth along the way. Need to appreciate this local species as they helped keep the rod bent during the colder days!

Tight lines!

Joe

Florida Outback

To start…what a year 2024 was on the water. In my typical (unacceptable) fashion, I find myself playing catchup on my fly fishing adventures from the year rather. I am committed in 2025 to make a much more diligent effort to do posts in real times after my outings, as it’s always fun to recap and keeps the blog updated in real time.

With all of that said, let’s hop into the 2024 adventures by discussing fishing for Barrramundi in Osceola, Florida. That’s right…Australian fish in Florida! This was hands down an opportunity that I wouldn’t have ever thought would exist in the United States, and I knew I had to make the time and effort to check it out.

Although the fishing was objectively not very challenging (as tons of fish were present), the fights, conditions, and getting eyes on a new species made it one to remember. These fish are here because of an outfitter that legally has been able to stock them for fishing and other commercial purposes. This is the only outfitter in the United States that has these fish.

Only about a 45-minute drive from some work I had in Orlando, I arrived to the property unsure of what to expect. The weather was abnormally cold for Florida, and the outfitter gave me a heads up that it could be a challenging day as these fish really need wam water to get amped up. With that said, I rigged up my 8-weight rod and had an assortment of strong-hooked flies that I typically use for saltwater ready to go. Within the first ten minutes of throwing a white bucktail fly, boom…

Joe Petrow – Barramundi

The take of these Barramundi is honestly something that I would compare to a tarpon. They fully engulf the fly with a huge open mouth, and when you strip set, it feels like you are trying to get a hook into a concrete block. With a few major jumps mixed in, these fish really are an ultimate game fish and I was extremely happy that I made the time to come check this place out. The fish were definitely a bit lethargic from the colder water (and the flies needed to be fished very slowly but yet sporadically to entire an eat), but was able to land more fish than I could count. The biggest trick to the day was making sure to have heavy enough line (straight 40 pound fluoro) and a strong wide gap hook to keep the fish on. The majority of the fish were between 8-12 pounds, but larger fish do exist that can be conquered in deeper water during the spring and summer in warmer weather. As for flies, anything that was white and 3-6″ inches long seemed to really be the ticket. As shared earlier, the sheer number of fish on the property makes it inevitable that success will be found, but adjusting to the conditions absolutely made it a much more productive day.

Sometimes it’s good to mix it up and go somewhere to get a pull on the line! This is a great example of that – I mean you can’t really ask for a better way to spend an afternoon in the middle of a colder January.

Tight lines!

Joe

The Others

For anyone that is a sports fan out there, you are probably familiar with “the others” concept when it comes to a team. For those that might have absolutely no clue what I’m talking about, “the others” is a term that is used to explain role (or bench) players on a team that are still needed to win games. Although “the others” are not the all-star, multi-million dollar, or biggest players that will sell out tickets in the stadium, they are often times the deciding factor in the outcome of any given game (as they will always swing the score by a couple of points, and bring the element of surprise along with them).

When it comes to fly fishing, “the others” are the awesome fish you catch that you were not anticipating to show up and that can save the overall day by making their presence known. For those who have read this blog, you know that I am slightly obsessed with catching all different kinds of species on the fly rod. I firmly believe that fly fishing should have no boundaries when it comes to the type of fish being pursued, and I also believe that many times people won’t pick up fly fishing because of incorrect assumptions that they live somewhere that isn’t ideal for it (i.e. “there are no trout where I live so I can’t fly fish”).

For capping off 2023, I thought it would be fun to highlight some of “the other” fish that I ran into this year in hopes of encouraging line to be thrown wherever you might be. By no means were these all of “the others” (as most outings are accompanied by surprise fish), but these were some coming to top of mind!

Bowfin – A fan favorite of mind. Prehistoric and pull like crazy. On this day I really was fishing for anything, but this guy made the morning special.

Joe Petrow – Bowfin

Redear Sunfish, Bluegill, Crappie, Green Sunfish, Redbreast Sunfish (in order below) – Sunfish in general are some of the most under-appreciated fish due to their size. Bluegill and Crappie are specifically are one of the most common freshwater fish to find in the US. Always fun running into these guys on a day of searching for Bass on a lake, or throwing small flies into creek systems just to see what is around. I even did some fish “saving” this year as was finding a ton in drying up pools of water at the end of the summer. Redbreast Sunfish are really unique from both a geographical standpoint and their overall looks.

Chain Pickerel – known also as a Slime Rocket, Ditch Pickle, or countless other names. These guys attack and eat flies like a baby Musky or Pike, and get way too much hate considering how fun they are to catch and how good looking they are.

Atlantic Pollock – These fish are a hoot. Ran into a pile of them while Striper fishing in Maine, and they kept the action steady in between Stripers. They pretty much will hit anything small and yellow it seems!

Croaker and Baby Redfish - Was able to get the paddleboard out on some flats for a hour here and there on two separate trips this year, and these guys made it worthwhile. The goal was to find some “big” Redfish up shallow, but the wind and dirty water had other plans (especially challenging with no boat). Regardless, these fish showed up and we appreciate the cooperation!

Bottom line here – appreciate what you catch. Every single fish is a “nice” fish. No need to discriminate or downplay, especially if you are putting the work and effort in to get out on the water (no matter how much time you have or what the conditions are).

Tight lines as always!

Joe

Heaven in Holbox

For those who have followed this blog over the years, our trips to Isla Holbox, Mexico are well documented. Perhaps the best juvenile tarpon fishery on planet earth (really not an exaggeration), this has continued to be our favorite international destination to chase the silver kings and princes that make this place home. Over the years, we have fished in Holbox several times in the early summer and winter (during breaks from school and work), but had never made it a point to visit in the late summer or early fall. In 2023, we decided to try Holbox out in late August, and man oh man did it deliver…

To keep it as short as I can, I saw more tarpon in our three days of fishing this year than I have ever seen before. The craziest part of it was not only was it the most tarpon I have ever seen, but they were the hungriest and most aggressive Holbox fish that we have ever come across. There were schools of fish by the hundreds, constant singles and double around almost every stretch of mangroves, and even large “roller” pods of bigger fish out in some of the deeper stretches of the bays. Really had never seen anything like it, and it led to an unreal three days on the water.

Day one really spoiled us from the jump. Upon the hour long boat ride to the flats, we ran across rolling fish just before we took off to the back mangroves, so took the time to stop and see if we could hook one of these fish. Upon rolling, you could tell that these fish were “larger” (30-50 pounds) and we were eager to see if the early morning light would have them feeling happy. Within 5 casts to the rolling group of fish, my line came tight and took off like a sky rocket. Fish on. Fishing in deeper water, not only was the fish doing its classic tarpon jumps and trying to shake the hook, but it was also making deep runs into the depths of the ocean making this fight even more excruciating. After about a 15-minute tug of war, we had the fish boatside and had the monkey quickly off our back for the week. A beautiful (dare I say perfect?) 40 pound fish in our hands, and we gave it a quick healthy release. After releasing this fish, our expectations for the day were high.

Joe Petrow – Tarpon

We continued to throw at the rolling fish for a bit, but ultimately decided to go back in the mangroves for the juvenile tarpon action. Fortunately for us, the fish were waiting and almost too aggressive as crazy as that might seem. We were hooking fish left and right, but were having a hell of a time getting them to the boat. I swear they were almost hitting the fly so quickly and taking off that we couldn’t get the right hook set, and quickly went 0-5 on hook ups to landed fish. Tarpon fishing, am I right? The good news though is we decided to suck less (and change flies to a different hook), and this immediately did the trick by landing the next handful of fish. Beautiful juvenile tarpon in hand with constant action throughout the day, what more can you ask for?

Joe Petrow – Tarpon
Joe Petrow – Tarpon

After seeing so many tarpon on Day 1, we decided to spend the morning going after permit on Day 2 (because we were playing with house money already). Permit had been making some appearances throughout the month, but in typical Permit fashion, were no where to be found this day. After a perfect throw to a passing bonefish (and it severely rejecting us), we took this as a sign that fate was leading us back to the baby tarpon. So we zipped over to some mangroves, and it was on again. What was special about this day was we were fishing in absolutely no more than 1-foot of water. Tarpon tails were out of the water, the sun was shining bright, and you needed to make the casts count. After going 3 for 3 on hook ups to landed fish this day, it was time to make the long boat ride back for a cold beer. A great day none-the-less.

Joe Petrow – Tarpon

As for the last day of fishing, this is where things got chaotic. My dad literally landed TEN (10) tarpon on this day. Unheard of really, especially considering there were easily another 10 that jumped off mid fight. The fish were schooling like crazy (in the hundreds), but it appeared that it was the single/double fish around the mangroves that were most aggressive. He absolutely made the most of his opportunity, and I think the word “legendary” is the only one that comes to mind when it comes to 10 tarpon on the day. As for me, it was an unreal day as well (and I fished with my uncle on this day). We ran into some difficult weather and rainstorms, but the fish did not seem to mind at all. I was able to land some fish on topwater gurglers early in the morning while they were smashing bait, and then consistently had success with our usual flies throughout the day. After landing 5-6 fish myself, it was a special day and a perfect way to end the trip.

Joe Petrow – Tarpon
Joe Petrow – Tarpon

To close this post, I do want to challenge anyone out there reading to make the time with those you love most on the water. I am beyond fortunate to have had my dad as my best friend and fishing partner for 30-years of my life, and although catching fish is special every single time they choose to cooperate, it’s the laughs and conversations over a margarita and taco that I wouldn’t trade for anything. Be grateful for what ya’ got and don’t take life/work/school/whatever too seriously during these moments.

Amen and tight lines!

Joe Petrow

Carp – Never Out of Style

Surprise, surprise, we have another post about carp. For those of you upset about it, not sorry. For those of you happy about it, I love you.

But for real and on a serious note, this past year was the definition of *elite* when it came to the carp fishing. Not only did the local waters fish excellent and produce some of our best fish to date, but I also had the opportunity to fish the famous canals around Scottsdale, Arizona and check out the carping scene there.

Let’s start with the Arizona carp. For starters, was there for a bachelor party weekend not focused on fishing, but still made it happen in less than desirable conditions. Best case fished for 2-hours each morning (early) as the hangovers were wearing off for the rest of the gentlemen and scholars at the AirbBNB. It was an unseasonably cold weekend in Arizona, but the fish did not seem to mind at all.

Not having fished in Arizona before, my best friend was Google Maps, and Uber’ing to a local park that had a handful of canals/ponds surrounding the premises proved to be the move . After about a 10-minute somewhat uncomfortable ride with the driver not understanding why I had a fishing rod with me, I entered a quiet residential park with practically no one else there. Literally upon exiting the vehicle and rigging up my 4-piece 6-weight rod, I was already seeing carp surface in the water around me. I also noticed some creek channels extending out of the ponds, to which I chose to explore those as the water was shallow and clear, and saw some fish moving. Within my first 10-minutes, I already was hooked up to a nice carp on one of my specialty home tie flies. Per usual carp fashion, the fish put up a great fight, and I was able to land a second fish shortly after in the same creek. The biggest fish of the morning came from one of the ponds themselves - a fish sunning in maybe 3-4 feet of water. Drag and dropped the fly right on its face, and bam. What a morning and one of the photos I was able to takee from it below:

As for the local carping this year, it continued to be one of my highlights for the summer. Although there were the recurring challenges with river conditions and clarity, when the water was clear and the sun was up, the fishing was unparalleled. Similar to last year, I found that late April and May produced the most fish (as they provided the largest schools I have ever seen – I’m talking 30+ fish in each school), but that fishing remained consistent until early September.

Joe Petrow – Carp
Joe Petrow – Carp
Joe Petrow – Carp

As always, the most effective way of catching these fish was on the micro skiff/stand up paddleboard, and exploring the backwater creeks off of the Chattahoochee river. One “newer” positive this year was that I caught more fish super shallow – i.e. less than a foot of water. Typically I am fishing for floating fish that are still over water that is 10+feet deep (which can be exceedingly challenging with the fly rod, as they can disappear upon desire), but now have some waters where it really is a true “flats” feel where wading is even possible if desired. One area I look forward to testing more in 2023 is trying to figure out the Grass Carp – there are a plethora in the river system that I fish, and although I’ve had some minimal luck, would be a ton of fun to figure out how to consistently hook into these fish. Have some plans to test out dry fly scenarios more with lighter tippet.

Was fortunate to have several outstanding sessions for the carp over the summer, and below you will find some of the best/highlighted fish we ran into. Overall, the favorite flies of the summer consisted of small damselfly nymphs, cottonseed patterns, as well as the occasional “wormy” looking thing when the conditions were right.

Joe Petrow – Carp
Joe Petrow – Carp
Joe Petrow – Carp

Thanks for the read and hope you are searching for some carp near you in 2024!